BBC rigging the election? A phone call to the BBC’s Ric Bailey….

kamsandhu —  November 7, 2014 — 11 Comments

Read the original article BBC Caught Rigging 2015 General Election?

By Ranjan Kumaran – @financialeyes

Last Friday, 31st October, a BBC Radio programme called Feedback asked why the BBC agreed to exclude the Green Party from the General Election TV debates.  (12 Minutes)

Ric Bailey, Chief Political Advisor to the BBC was invited onto the show.

Image: BBC News

Ric Bailey Image: BBC News

When asked to justify his stance by the radio presenter, Bailey replied;

“When we’re approaching an election or for any of our coverage for that matter, we look really carefully at the objective evidence of electoral support.

“In the approach to a General Election our starting point is what happened atthe last General Election, 2010. But that’s not everything, we also look at any other evidence of electoral support and change of electoral support – we look at opinion polls so we’re applying very objective criteria.

“Opinion polls are only one part of the equation – and the key phrase is a consistent and robust trend – so if you look at UKIP over a very long period – and I’m talking about literally hundreds of opinion polls you can see that there is a substantial increase in support for UKIP which is incidentally backed up by real people voting in polling booths.”

When asked about ‘the Green Surge’, Bailey quoted figures which demonstrate that the Greens have been outperformed by UKIP. He made no mention of any figure favourable to the Greens and followed up by saying – “so we look at these really objectively.”

Ever since he mentioned them, I’ve been looking for these objective criteria.

Part of me doesn’t believe they exist and the other part has decided to pretend they do.

So how am I supposed to find them?

I sent a freedom of information request which was refused, as mentioned previously.

I needed another approach. I called a political journalist. He told me he was sure he had seen the criteria and the weightings applied to election performance and opinion polls online sometime. I googled away and got nowhere. I decided there was no other option. I was going to have to call Ric Bailey. He didn’t seem so high up in the organisation that he wouldn’t answer his own phone. Nor, from his performance on TV and the radio, did I feel he deserved to be.

I googled his name and telephone number and up it came. He’s been treating people with disdain, I told myself. Don’t forget that. Let him say what he likes, but press him for an answer.

The phone rang a couple of times and, at 16:30, he answered the phone.

I asked him what criteria the BBC applied when agreeing to allow UKIP to appear in the Leaders’ debates at the expense of the Greens.

I told him I was talking about statistical methodologies, datasets, opinion polls and elections.

He said it was all available online.

I asked him where.

He said “It’s not all in one place.”

I asked him for the names of the datasets.

He said, “All of them”. Not helpful. Incredibly vague.

I asked him about methodologies. I was hoping he could name an approach, a formula, some weightings. He did not. He said that UKIP have surged and this was obvious. That ‘due weight’ is an editorial judgement. That this is basically private. There are no statistical thresholds.

I told him he has cherry picked the data to exclude the Greens. This he denied. He asked for a relevant stat which he had left out. I told him one. He quoted another. We danced like this for 25 minutes and neither of us got anywhere.

That a man with no grasp whatsoever about how to process statistical information is fronting the campaign to sell the BBC interpretation of opinion poll and election results shows they just don’t care. That’s it. They hold the licence-payer in complete contempt.

This organisation is so out of touch that it is now threatening its own existence.

His contact details were available online:

Ric Bailey, Chief Adviser, Politics, BBC Editorial Policy and Standards

07889 852195 – 0208 00 81805

Speaking to this man is a waste of time if you are looking for any truthful answers about the statistical methods he and his colleagues have pretended to use.

I don’t know what is more disturbing. The fact that drones like Bailey are allowed to act as they do or the fact that we don’t do more to question the flimsiness of his arguments. Redundant information serves as a distraction from the heist that people like him are fronting.

Bring on the Real Media. Please Share.

Like us on Facebook / Follow us on Twitter

Sign up for updates via info@realfare.co.uk
Advertisements

kamsandhu

Posts

kambass@hotmail.co.uk

11 responses to BBC rigging the election? A phone call to the BBC’s Ric Bailey….

  1. 

    Reblogged this on markcatlin3695's Blog and commented:
    It gets more and more obvious to me that we don’t have a free and impartial press in this country. I’m not certain we ever had one to be honest, it’s just now it seems they don’t seem to care whether we know they’re full of right-wing hatred for most of the population, and greed and the few are all they and the rest of the presstitutes in the world care about.

  2. 
    Michael Aydinian November 7, 2014 at 10:16 pm

    If it’s Zionist controlled – IT’S RIGGED!

  3. 

    This is the wrong argument in any case: the media reporting is what to a large extent creates the opinions that the polls are measuring. Parties that don’t get publicised, won’t appear in the polls.

    The BBC goes out of its way to be ‘balanced’ when it comes to global warming, even to the extent of hunting out the 1% of pundits who don’t believe in it and giving them equal weight to the 99% of experts who do, and can prove it. Applying similar rules, there should be more Greens and Monster Raving Loonies etc. than the main three parties, enjoying coverage in the run up to a *democratic* election.

  4. 

    everything is rigged welfare figures for esa jsa etc and money is stopped no hardship payments no crisis loans A T O S is a joke on the ordainary working person who happens to be too sick to work A T O S finds them fit for work by inventing thing that don,t take place and omitting thing that actually happen unles you have family to hold you up until things get sorted you could die or lose your housing as you,ve no income and your mp won,t get involved to help you you can work for 30 years pay inc tax and nat ins it counts for nothing i,m afraid i,ve completely lost faith in our government or any other to be elected 2015. what we were told to do was fraud so we did not do it unstead there,s been no money for 6 weeks so far and people say our welfare system is generous l don,t think so.

  5. 

    Anyone who believes in an unbiased press after the fiasco of the Scottish independence referendum is deluded.

  6. 

    Ric Bailey is the man who drew up then completely ignored the draft guidelines for the indyref.

    He and his fellow senior staff at the BBC are all liars and propagandists. They are deliberately trying to set the political agenda.

    Their arrogance and disdain are evident. In fact they are in breach of their charter, their guidelines and of the trust by the public. It is likely they are in breach of their contractual obligations.

    They are a blight on the BBC and society.

  7. 

    The SNP are the third largest party in the ‘UK’ and presently have Six MP,s, yet your argument is solely centred on the Greens. Seems the BBC are not the only ones with a Blind Spot!

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. BBC RIGGING THE ELECTION? A PHONE CALL TO BBC’s RIC BAILEY - November 10, 2014

    […] Crossposted from Realfare […]

  2. The Media & NHS deregulation « REALFARE - November 21, 2014

    […] Who knows. I’d love to FOI the BBC about this but you can’t get any sense out of an unregulated regime broadcaster whose incomplete and therefore erroneous reporting is constantly defended as ‘editorial independence’. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s